Surprise My Pet Review - UPDATED Oct 2025

– – – Important Update – – – 

As of late 2019 Surprise My Pet subscription box is no longer available. We recommend you check out The Best Monthly Pet Subscription Boxes instead.

– – – Important Update – – – 

About Surprise My Pet

Surprise My Pet is a family-owned service that will deliver a pet subscription box to your door every month. Each box brings you a monthly supply of high-quality pet goodies. The service offers boxes for both cats and dogs. Surprise My Pet boxes typically contain 5 to 7 hand-picked items. You will receive nutritious, all-natural treats and chews, made in the USA, as well as fun toys that will keep your furry companion actively engaged. The service may even include a picture of your pet on the insert card that arrives in each box. The combined retail value of these items is significantly higher than the price you pay as a subscriber.

Different boxes are provided for tiny, small, medium and large dogs, but the price is the same. If you choose the monthly subscription, you pay $30 every month. The 3-month subscription costs $84, which amounts to $28 per box. With the yearly subscription, which costs $312 ($26 per box), you can save over 13%.

For cat lovers, Surprise My Pet offers Single-Cat Family and Multi-Cat Family boxes. The Single-Cat box costs $30 with a monthly subscription. If you have 2 or more cats, Multi-Cat boxes, which cost $37 per month, may be the right choice for you. You can save some money if you pay in advance for 3 or 12 months. Shipping is free in the USA with all subscription plans.

Surprise My Pet donates a part of its profits to pet-focused charities. As a subscriber, you can submit a charity in your local area to be considered for a donation.

Pricing and Shipping

• Price: $FROM $24
• Shipping cost: FREE IN US
• Ships from: United States
• Ships to: United States